Competency Explorer Feature Analysis: Difference between revisions

From T3 Network Wiki
(→‎OCFC Required Features: sorting out format, adding a couple more features)
(adding required features)
Line 9: Line 9:
The [[OCF_Collab_Network:rwscUCanalysis|TAW's analysis of use cases]] produced by the RWSC identified new features or capabilities required for the OCFC to meet those requirements. In this page those new features are collated in order to provide the basis for work plans for projects that can enhance the OCFC.
The [[OCF_Collab_Network:rwscUCanalysis|TAW's analysis of use cases]] produced by the RWSC identified new features or capabilities required for the OCFC to meet those requirements. In this page those new features are collated in order to provide the basis for work plans for projects that can enhance the OCFC.


==Cluster One==
==Competency discovery==
===Search capabilities===
===Search capabilities===


===== '''Search by work roles (or occupation/job/specialty) to find & display associated competencies.''' =====
==== Search by work roles (or occupation/job/speciality) to find & display associated competencies. ====
Required by:  
Required by:  
*'''1 Document Competencies.''' As an instructional designer, I need to work with faculty to document competencies addressed by their courses in order to to support adequate student assessment as aligned to a particular job role.
*'''1 Document Competencies.''' As an instructional designer, I need to work with faculty to document competencies addressed by their courses in order to to support adequate student assessment as aligned to a particular job role.
**'''In order to:''' find the competencies and provide the documentation about them.
**'''In order to:''' find the competencies and provide the documentation about them.
**'''Assuming:''' Competency data with links to/from workroles (or occupations/jobs/specialties) exist in the registry data.
**'''Assuming:''' Competency data with links to/from workroles (or occupations/jobs/specialities) exist in the registry data.


===== '''Return results based on a competency description''' =====
==== Return results based on a competency description ====
Required by:  
Required by:  


Line 28: Line 28:
**'''Assuming that:''' Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.
**'''Assuming that:''' Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.


===== '''Results returned have some indication of how close the match between the query and the results.''' =====
==== Given a competency description and target frameworks, identify and return the closest matching competencies in the target framework. ====
Required by:
 
* '''6 Align Credentials to Industry Recognized Frameworks.''' As a designer of digital credentials, I need to align the competencies of those credentials to the competencies in the most recognized industry frameworks used by specific employers.
** This may be a "bulk process", i.e. provide an array of competency descriptions, get matches for each.
** '''In order to:''' allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
** '''Assuming:''' Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some indication of industry recognition.
 
==== Given a description of a training competency and an industry, find other relevant competency descriptions ====
Required by:
 
* '''''7'' Map Training to Industry Recognized Frameworks.''' As an employer issuing digital badges / micro-credentials to employees for internal training, I need to map the training competencies to competencies in recognized industry competency frameworks.
** '''In order to:''' Allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
** '''Assuming that:''' Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some means of identifying the relevant industry.
 
==== Given a means of identifying an industry, find frameworks relevant to it. ====
Required by:
 
* '''''7'' Map Training to Industry Recognized Frameworks.''' As an employer issuing digital badges / micro-credentials to employees for internal training, I need to map the training competencies to competencies in recognized industry competency frameworks.
** '''In order to:''' Allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
** '''Assuming that:''' Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some means of identifying the relevant industry.
 
==== Results returned have some indication of how close the match between the query and the results. ====
Required by:
Required by:


Line 37: Line 59:
**'''In order to''': Help instructional designer find relevant competencies based on info provide by employer.  
**'''In order to''': Help instructional designer find relevant competencies based on info provide by employer.  
**'''Assuming that:''' Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.
**'''Assuming that:''' Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.
*'''6 Align Credentials to Industry Recognized Frameworks.''' As a designer of digital credentials, I need to align the competencies of those credentials to the competencies in the most recognized industry frameworks used by specific employers.
** This may be a "bulk process", i.e. provide an array of competency descriptions, get matches for each.
** '''In order to:''' allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
** '''Assuming:''' Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some indication of industry recognition.


===Result display requirements===
===Result display requirements===


==== '''Show the relationship between a competency and workrole(s) (etc.)''' when the data is available. ====
==== Show the relationship between a competency and workrole(s) (etc.) when the data is available. ====
Required by:  
Required by:  


Line 47: Line 73:
**'''Assuming:''' Competency data with links to/from workroles (or occupations/jobs/specialties) exist in the registry data.
**'''Assuming:''' Competency data with links to/from workroles (or occupations/jobs/specialties) exist in the registry data.


==== '''Show those properties that contextualize the competence, e.g. links to courses, jobs,''' if they exist. ====
==== Show those properties that contextualize the competence, e.g. links to courses, jobs, if they exist. ====
Required by:
Required by:


* '''3. Mapping Competencies.''' As an instructional designer at an educational provider, I need to map skills and competencies identified by an employer looking for training opportunities to the skills and competencies in the college's courses and training programs.
* '''3. Mapping Competencies.''' As an instructional designer at an educational provider, I need to map skills and competencies identified by an employer looking for training opportunities to the skills and competencies in the college's courses and training programs.
**'''In order to:''' help instructional designer find relevant competencies based on info provide by employer.
**'''Assuming that:''' Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.
==== Display information / link to information about creators of a framework. ====
Required by:
* '''4 Selection Criteria Creator Information.''' As an instructional designer searching for competency frameworks to guide course development, I need sufficient descriptive information about the type and status of the creators of each framework such as profit vs. non-profit, industry group, academic.
** '''In order to:''' Provide information about creators of frameworks.
** '''Assuming that:''' given a link to the framework creator's website the required information can be found.
==== Provide access to related documentation. ====
Required by:
* '''''5'' Strength of Fit.''' As an organization, we need to statistically measure the similarities or strength of fit between competencies in two different competency frameworks that have been published by two different organizations and expressed, perhaps, in different meta-models (via both algorithmic transparency and provision of good documentation).
** '''In order to:''' Provide access to the definitions of the identified competencies in the required meta-model, and a measure of similarity.
** '''Assuming that:''' Links to the documentation exist.
==Services in addition to search==
=== Mapping different statements of similar competencies. ===
====Measure similarity between competencies.====
Required by:
* '''''5'' Strength of Fit.''' As an organization, we need to statistically measure the similarities or strength of fit between competencies in two different competency frameworks that have been published by two different organizations and expressed, perhaps, in different meta-models (via both algorithmic transparency and provision of good documentation).


==Cluster Two (mapping)==
Could also support requirement that results returned have some indication of how close the match between the query and the results (see above).
 
==== Provide information about how measure of similarity was arrived at. ====
Required by:


Some relevance to:
* '''''5'' Strength of Fit.''' As an organization, we need to statistically measure the similarities or strength of fit between competencies in two different competency frameworks that have been published by two different organizations and expressed, perhaps, in different meta-models (via both algorithmic transparency and provision of good documentation).


* results returned have some indication of how close the match between the query and the results.
=== Analysis of competence related data ===


* Required by: 2. Alignment of Competencies.
==== Determine the "most recognized frameworks" ====
E.g. based on usage statistics or links made to framework etc.


Required by


* '''''6'' Align Credentials to Industry Recognized Frameworks.''' As a designer of digital credentials, I need to align the competencies of those credentials to the competencies in the most recognized industry frameworks used by specific employers


==Stand-alone & non-technical requirements==
==Stand-alone & non-technical requirements==

Revision as of 10:08, 1 July 2022

>> OCFCollab Home >> RWSC | TAW >> OCFC Required Features

Usecaseslogo.png

OCFC Required Features

This page is currently an incomplete draft.

The TAW's analysis of use cases produced by the RWSC identified new features or capabilities required for the OCFC to meet those requirements. In this page those new features are collated in order to provide the basis for work plans for projects that can enhance the OCFC.

Competency discovery

Search capabilities

Search by work roles (or occupation/job/speciality) to find & display associated competencies.

Required by:

  • 1 Document Competencies. As an instructional designer, I need to work with faculty to document competencies addressed by their courses in order to to support adequate student assessment as aligned to a particular job role.
    • In order to: find the competencies and provide the documentation about them.
    • Assuming: Competency data with links to/from workroles (or occupations/jobs/specialities) exist in the registry data.

Return results based on a competency description

Required by:

  • 2. Alignment of Competencies. As a competency frameworks developer, I need to align the skills and competencies in my frameworks to the skills and competencies in other frameworks using links defining levels of similarity to assist in interoperability with organizations using those frameworks.
    • In order to: find competencies in frameworks that are described in one or more nodes.
  • 3 Mapping Competencies. As an instructional designer at an educational provider, I need to map skills and competencies identified by an employer looking for training opportunities to the skills and competencies in the college's courses and training programs.
    • In order to: Help instructional designer find relevant competencies based on info provide by employer.
    • Assuming that: Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.

Given a competency description and target frameworks, identify and return the closest matching competencies in the target framework.

Required by:

  • 6 Align Credentials to Industry Recognized Frameworks. As a designer of digital credentials, I need to align the competencies of those credentials to the competencies in the most recognized industry frameworks used by specific employers.
    • This may be a "bulk process", i.e. provide an array of competency descriptions, get matches for each.
    • In order to: allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
    • Assuming: Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some indication of industry recognition.

Given a description of a training competency and an industry, find other relevant competency descriptions

Required by:

  • 7 Map Training to Industry Recognized Frameworks. As an employer issuing digital badges / micro-credentials to employees for internal training, I need to map the training competencies to competencies in recognized industry competency frameworks.
    • In order to: Allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
    • Assuming that: Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some means of identifying the relevant industry.

Given a means of identifying an industry, find frameworks relevant to it.

Required by:

  • 7 Map Training to Industry Recognized Frameworks. As an employer issuing digital badges / micro-credentials to employees for internal training, I need to map the training competencies to competencies in recognized industry competency frameworks.
    • In order to: Allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
    • Assuming that: Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some means of identifying the relevant industry.

Results returned have some indication of how close the match between the query and the results.

Required by:

  • 2. Alignment of Competencies. As a competency frameworks developer, I need to align the skills and competencies in my frameworks to the skills and competencies in other frameworks using links defining levels of similarity to assist in interoperability with organizations using those frameworks.
    • In order to: document an alignment between competencies
  • 3 Mapping Competencies: As an instructional designer at an educational provider, I need to map skills and competencies identified by an employer looking for training opportunities to the skills and competencies in the college's courses and training programs.
    • In order to: Help instructional designer find relevant competencies based on info provide by employer.
    • Assuming that: Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.
  • 6 Align Credentials to Industry Recognized Frameworks. As a designer of digital credentials, I need to align the competencies of those credentials to the competencies in the most recognized industry frameworks used by specific employers.
    • This may be a "bulk process", i.e. provide an array of competency descriptions, get matches for each.
    • In order to: allow the user to identify the relevant competencies in recognized industry frameworks.
    • Assuming: Competency descriptions are in frameworks with some indication of industry recognition.

Result display requirements

Show the relationship between a competency and workrole(s) (etc.) when the data is available.

Required by:

  • 1 Document Competencies. As an instructional designer, I need to work with faculty to document competencies addressed by their courses in order to to support adequate student assessment as aligned to a particular job role.
    • In order to: find the competencies and provide the documentation about them.
    • Assuming: Competency data with links to/from workroles (or occupations/jobs/specialties) exist in the registry data.

Show those properties that contextualize the competence, e.g. links to courses, jobs, if they exist.

Required by:

  • 3. Mapping Competencies. As an instructional designer at an educational provider, I need to map skills and competencies identified by an employer looking for training opportunities to the skills and competencies in the college's courses and training programs.
    • In order to: help instructional designer find relevant competencies based on info provide by employer.
    • Assuming that: Data on competencies that are learning objectives of courses are available to the search service.

Display information / link to information about creators of a framework.

Required by:

  • 4 Selection Criteria Creator Information. As an instructional designer searching for competency frameworks to guide course development, I need sufficient descriptive information about the type and status of the creators of each framework such as profit vs. non-profit, industry group, academic.
    • In order to: Provide information about creators of frameworks.
    • Assuming that: given a link to the framework creator's website the required information can be found.

Provide access to related documentation.

Required by:

  • 5 Strength of Fit. As an organization, we need to statistically measure the similarities or strength of fit between competencies in two different competency frameworks that have been published by two different organizations and expressed, perhaps, in different meta-models (via both algorithmic transparency and provision of good documentation).
    • In order to: Provide access to the definitions of the identified competencies in the required meta-model, and a measure of similarity.
    • Assuming that: Links to the documentation exist.

Services in addition to search

Mapping different statements of similar competencies.

Measure similarity between competencies.

Required by:

  • 5 Strength of Fit. As an organization, we need to statistically measure the similarities or strength of fit between competencies in two different competency frameworks that have been published by two different organizations and expressed, perhaps, in different meta-models (via both algorithmic transparency and provision of good documentation).

Could also support requirement that results returned have some indication of how close the match between the query and the results (see above).

Provide information about how measure of similarity was arrived at.

Required by:

  • 5 Strength of Fit. As an organization, we need to statistically measure the similarities or strength of fit between competencies in two different competency frameworks that have been published by two different organizations and expressed, perhaps, in different meta-models (via both algorithmic transparency and provision of good documentation).

Analysis of competence related data

Determine the "most recognized frameworks"

E.g. based on usage statistics or links made to framework etc.

Required by

  • 6 Align Credentials to Industry Recognized Frameworks. As a designer of digital credentials, I need to align the competencies of those credentials to the competencies in the most recognized industry frameworks used by specific employers

Stand-alone & non-technical requirements